Asics Scarpe Gel-Challenger 13 Clay | Our verdict
- Our top pick in asics gel nimbus 22 lite show black red women
- Our top pick in Asics Scarpe Gel-Challenger 13 Clay
Pros
- Fantastic value
- Asics Gel-Kayano Trainer Evo Marathon Running Shoes Sneakers H821N-4242
- Enough stack height
- Stable ride
- Good for heel strikers
- Ready for hiking
- ASICS Gel-1090 1203A243-001
Cons
- Durability could be better
- Lacks energy return
- Heavy
Audience verdict
- ASICS Gel Excite 9 Black New Leaf Hombre trail running shoes
- Top 29% in comfortable running shoes
- Top 20% most popular running shoes
Asics Scarpe Gel-Challenger 13 Clay | Comparison
The most similar running shoes compared
+ + ASICS 5 Birch Beige Birch Beige 1191A202-201 | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Audience score | 89 Great! | 81 Good! | 85 Good! | 83 Good! | |
Price | $80 | $90 | $145 | $100 | |
Trail terrain | LightModerate | LightModerate | LightModerate | Light | |
Arch support | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | |
Weight lab Weight brand | 11.1 oz / 314g 10.6 oz / 300g | 11 ASICS Contend 7 TS 1014A202-405 11.5 Asics Gel Trabuco 9 Goretex Παπούτσια Για Τρέξιμο Trail | 8.8 oz / 250g 8.8 oz / 250g | 9.9 Asics Kort Ärm T-Shirt Padel 10.4 oz / 294.8g | |
Drop lab Drop brand | 10.4 mm ‐ | 8.2 mm ‐ | 8.8 mm 5.0 mm | 9.2 mm 8.0 mm | |
Strike pattern | Heel | HeelMid/forefoot | HeelMid/forefoot | HeelMid/forefoot | |
Midsole softness | Balanced | Balanced | Soft | Balanced | |
zapatillas de running ASICS ritmo medio pie arco bajo talla 17.5 | Normal | Small | Normal | Big | |
Toebox durability | Very bad | Decent | Good | Bad | |
asics gel lyte iii og aqua angel 1201a051 400 release date info | Decent | Bad | Decent | Bad | |
Outsole durability | - | Good | - | Decent | |
Breathability | Moderate | Moderate | Warm | Moderate | |
Toebox width at the widest part | Medium | Medium | Medium | Medium | |
ASICS Gel-Quantum 180 RE Black Carrier Grey | Narrow | Narrow | Narrow | Medium | |
Stiffness | Moderate | Moderate | Flexible | Moderate | |
Difference in stiffness in cold | Big | Small | Big | Normal | |
Torsional rigidity | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate | |
Asics Lenkkitossut Gel Cumulus 20 | Stiff | Moderate | Stiff | Stiff | |
Lug depth | 3.0 mm | 2.9 mm | 3.1 mm | 2.7 mm | |
Asics Gel Lyte 3 White Black Yellow Lime votsketm asics south africa replica cap mens | 33.3 mm ‐ | 33.8 mm ‐ | 32.9 mm 31.0 mm | 32.1 mm 30.0 mm | |
Forefoot lab Forefoot brand | 22.9 mm ‐ | 25.6 mm ‐ | 24.1 mm 26.0 mm | 22.9 mm 22.0 mm | |
Widths available | NormalWideX-Wide | NormalWideX-Wide | NormalWide | Normal | |
tenis infantil asics buzz 4 gs rosa branco | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ✓ | |
Season | All seasons | All seasons | All seasons | All seasons | |
Removable insole | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
Orthotic friendly | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | |
Ranking | #78 Top 30% | #234 Bottom 10% | #183 Bottom 30% | #217 Bottom 17% | |
Popularity | #52 Top 20% | #233 Bottom 11% | #28 Top 11% | #161 Bottom 38% |
Who should buy
We believe this ASICS trail shoe is an ideal choice for runners seeking:
- Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Mens
- A versatile all-rounder that handles trail running, hiking, and even road running when necessary
- A shoe with a classic design that doesn't draw undue attention.
Who should NOT buy
If you're in the market searching for a bouncy ride with a higher-end feel or waterproof features, steer clear of these ASICS. Instead, we suggest taking a look at the Nike React Pegasus Trail 4 (or its GTX edition).
If you're looking for a durable shoe that offers great value for your money, we still recommend going with an ASICS option, specifically the Trail Scout 2, based on our lab tests.
Breathability
Breathability is a major concern for many trail runners, since it's difficult to come across trail shoes with a well-ventilated upper. We performed our jaw-dropping smoke test, and we were astounded by how fantastic this shoe performs in this aspect.
Even when the trails felt like embers, our feet remained well ventilated!
It performs admirably due to its mesh upper. The mesh is sufficiently dense to prevent light from passing through—as seen in the video below—yet it's thin enough to allow for proper airflow. It's a winning combination.
However, how can we determine why it breathes so well? We conducted a examination of the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens under our microscope.
It is the aforementioned thin mesh that takes credit for the impressive 4/5 in the breathability test.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 4 |
Average | 3.4 |
Durability
Toebox durability
The Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens took a serious hit in our lab tests, scoring an unfortunate 1 out of 5, the lowest score possible. We had braced ourselves for a low score, anticipating it even before the Dremel test, due to the shoe's thin mesh. However, the result still left us truly disappointed.

We subjected both shoes to the same test (3.2N @ 10K RPM), and the results were clear as day.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 1 |
Average | 3.1 |
asics gel lyte iii og aqua angel 1201a051 400 release date info
Sometimes, a shoe surprises us with stellar scores in the toebox area, only to baratas in the heel. Or the other way around. Unfortunately, we didn't encounter such luck this time. After white our Dremel test on the heel, we handed out a below-average score of 2 out of 5 to the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 2 |
Average | 2.9 |
Outsole hardness
As a budget-friendly trail shoe, we anticipated an average score when we used our durometer to test the softness of the outsole. That's exactly what we got: 84.5 HC.
This outsole should easily extend beyond 700 miles, provided that you don't subject it to too many road runs, of course.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 84.5 HC |
Average | 85.4 HC |
Outsole thickness
The outsole boasts an average thickness. With a robust 2.5 mm—a little behind the average—of rubber beneath the lugs, it's more than capable of assuring an adequate lifespan.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 2.5 mm |
Average | 2.4 mm |
Weight
When we first held the shoe in our hands, we could tell it was far from being feather-light. Our suspicion was confirmed upon placing it on our scale—the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens tipped the scales at a substantial 11.1 oz (314g), hurdling over the famous 10-ounce barrier.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 11.08 oz (314g) |
Average | 10.34 oz (293g) |
Cushioning
Heel stack
We were taken aback when we used our caliper to measure the stack height in the heel. It's not everyday that we stumble upon high-stack shoes boasting an impressive 33.3 mm of foam in the rearfoot!

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 33.3 mm |
Average | 32.3 mm |
Forefoot stack
On the flip side, we were equally taken aback by how thin the forefoot was. With a stack height of 22.9 mm—below the average trail shoe—that includes both the outsole, the insole and the lugs, there's not a lot of cushioning in that area. It's clear to us, this is a shoe built with heel strikers in mind!

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 22.9 mm |
Average | 24.6 mm |
Drop
The significant 10.4-mm heel-to-toe drop simply reaffirms our earlier observations. Such a high drop caters well to those who hit the trails heel-first. And that's exactly what this shoe delivers.
It's worth noting that budget-friendly trail shoes, often targeted towards beginners or slower-paced runners, tend to boast a quite-steep drop.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 10.4 mm |
Average | 7.7 mm |
Insole thickness
The insole, with its comfortable 4.8 mm of thickness—just a touch above the average—it's just what we wanted.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 4.8 mm |
Average | 4.7 mm |
Midsole softness
At 24.6 HA, this isn't your run-of-the-mill midsole softness that was the norm on trail shoes! Amplifoam delivers a soft and gentle touch—but don't expect an over-the-top bounce from the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens, especially considering it's an $80 trail shoe.
If you're on the hunt for a springy trail running shoe, consider checking out the Schuhe Asics Gel-Contend 7 1012A911 Black Carrier Grey 001, ASICS Gel-Nimbus 24 Green Marathon Running Shoes 1011B359-750.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 24.6 HA |
Average | 22.6 HA |
zapatillas de running ASICS ritmo medio pie arco bajo talla 17.5
While the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens may not be the ideal pick for winter trail running due to its outstanding ventilation, it becomes a great choice under cold temperatures when paired with thick socks.
After we checked the midsole softness in cold temperatures, we noticed that the foam might firm up slightly more than we prefer (up to 34.4 HA), but it still maintains a below-average firmness—a remarkable achievement for such a budget-friendly shoe.
While it doesn't turn stone-hard, you'll surely feel the shift as it becomes 39.7% firmer under cold conditions. That's a typical response for EVA-based foam, as you can see in our advanced guide.
For a shoe that shines in winter, consider the Chaussures ASICS Noosa Tri 14 1012B208 Pink Glo Black 700 with its TPU-based midsole.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 39.7% |
Average | 26.4% |
Stability
Lateral stability test
With a stack that's above average and a cushy foam, one wouldn't typically anticipate excellent stability. Yet, these ASICS shoes left us with a great impression. Their Amplifoam midsole was stable in our runs and comfy during long hikes.
Torsional rigidity
The solid stability in the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens largely comes from its 3/5 torsional rigidity. Like nearly all other trail running shoes, it's not super flexible. That rigidity, however, works in our favor, helping us remain stable on any terrain.
Кроссовки asics man's court ff novac clay.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 3 |
Average | 3.5 |
Asics Lenkkitossut Gel Cumulus 20
This shoe scores an impressive 4 out of 5 on our heel stiffness test, putting it well above the average trail shoe and providing a guided run. Since it's not advertised or designed for fast paces, this rating just make sense to us.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 4 |
Average | 3.1 |
mens asics sports clothing coats jackets
The landing platform doesn't hold any surprises. Using our caliper for precise measurements, we found that the midsole width is about average in the forefoot (109.5 mm), just 2 mm less than most trail shoes.
For those who overpronate, a wider shoe such as the Asics x Vivienne Westwood Gel-Kayano V 5 2019 or the zapatillas de running ASICS pronador talla 46 Asics Tarther Sc Marathon Running Shoes Sneakers 1203A125-300.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 109.5 mm |
Average | 112.1 mm |
Midsole width in the heel
Like they did with the steep heel-to-toe drop, ASICS pleased the heel strikers again with a midsole width that's wider than most shoes. At 89.5 mm, it will be really stable everywhere!

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 89.5 mm |
Average | 89.8 mm |
Flexibility
Stiffness
Using our force gauge tool, it took us only 20.1N to bend the shoe to a 90-degree angle. This is 58% less than the average force, making this shoe one of the most flexible trail shoes we've ever put to the test in our lab.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 20.1N |
Average | 28.1N |
Difference in stiffness in cold
Thanks to its low-end longitudinal flexibility, it doesn't stiffen excessively in cold temperatures. In fact, after a 20-minute exposure to freezing conditions, it only required 32N to bend it to 90 degrees—nearly the same force needed to flex the average shoe at room temperature.
That said, the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens does display a notable 59.3% increase in stiffness from its normal state at room temperature. We find this significant as it results in a firmer feel compared to other shoes, largely due to this substantial change.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 59.3% |
Average | 35% |
Grip / Traction
Lug depth
We enjoyed the versatility of the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens during both runs and hikes. This is partly due to its below-average-sized lugs—measuring just 3 mm.
These lugs are perfect for quick hikes and a wide range of running speeds. However, we noticed the performance getting worse on more challenging terrain. It's clear that no shoe can excel in every scenario!

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 3.0 mm |
Average | 3.6 mm |
Size and fit
Toebox width at the widest part
The toe box doesn't offer much wiggle room at 97 mm of width, but it's sufficient for most foot types. We firmly advise that this shoe is suitable for narrow, medium, and somewhat wide feet.
However, if you've got ultra-wide feet, you should probably steer clear. Brands like Altra ASICS Gel 1130 Slate Grey Piedmont Grey Hombre.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 97.0 mm |
Average | 98.9 mm |
ASICS Gel-Quantum 180 RE Black Carrier Grey
At 72.3 mm, the shoe narrows by 34.2% from the widest point to the area of the big toe, being 30% the average.
Based on our tests, we find that it's a better match for those who have a significant size difference between their big toe and the rest—think Greek or Egyptian foot shapes. In contrast, those with Celtic, German, and Roman feet should definitely avoid the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens and, again, try something from Altra like the Lone Peak 7.
For more information on uppers and foot shapes, check out our guide about uppers, Camiseta ASICS AOP GPX Masculina Preta.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 72.3 mm |
Average | 79.1 mm |
Toebox feel

Midfoot feel
The midfoot area feels absolutely normal. Our tests suggest that even those among us with flat feet should find it comfortable.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | Normal |
Heel feel
Then, there's the heel—it pleasantly surprised us with its slightly-wider-than-average Buty while retaining a fair bit of rigidity. This strikes a fine balance between comfort and stability.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | Normal |
asics jolt 2 zapatillas de running
A common shortfall of budget trail shoes is their lack of a gusseted tongue. Could ASICS have added one? Definitely, but no chance they do that. They need to distinguish budget shoes from high-end ones, and leaving out this feature is a really easy way to do it.
So, predictably, there's no gusset in the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens, opening the door for debris, dust, and small rocks to easily get inside the shoe.

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | None |
Comfort
The Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens offers suitable padding, particularly in the heel area, providing substantial comfort. The only drawback we've noticed in our examination—which is common in trail shoes—is that the mesh can feel a bit rough.
Tongue padding
Recently, we've noticed a trend of super-thick tongues on trail running shoes, like in the Salomon Ultra Glide 2. In most cases, this trend proves more of a downside, leading to uncomfortably snug fits and added weight. However, the Japan-based brand has navigated this issue, featuring a comfortable yet light 5-mm tongue. Kudos, ASICS!

Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | 5.0 mm |
Average | 6.5 mm |
Removable insole
In the Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens, we were able to switch out the insole for a thicker and thinner one. Swapping your own orthotics is also a possibility.
Asics Icon Short Sleeve T Shirt Womens | Yes |