Altra Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX review

Heel padding durability:

• Hikers in the market for an incredibly comfy zero-drop hiking boot for less challenging terrains
• Speedy hikers looking for a nimble and lightweight boot that feels more like a trail runner underfoot
• Year-round adventurers who need a boot that performs consistently from blustering summer treks to frigid winter hauls. 
• Casual hikers looking for a boot that's good for long hauls as well as quick strolls through the park or around town
• Those with broad feet prone to hotspots and blisters in need of a snug but accommodating toebox 

While the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX provides excellent traction on dirt trails, we felt decidedly less surefooted on gravelly or rocky trails. For advanced hikers who frequently traverse more technical trails, we recommend the more aggressive La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX instead. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX is weatherproof, but not waterproof. So while the boot will keep our feet relatively dry during rainfall, it won't help much when wading through riverbeds or streams. For those who need to keep their feet dry, especially in the colder months, we recommend the Add a shoe instead. 

The flexibility of the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX certainly contributes to its comfy, trail-shoe vibe, but also detracts from its stability. Especially as the mile markers wear on and foot fatigue sets in. Backpackers looking to schlep heavy loads across vast distances will be better served by a more stable boot like the much heavier but supportive Heel stack lab.

The instability of the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX will feel even more pronounced for those with narrow feet who will have to put in more effort to stabilise their landings as their feet swim around in the toebox. For a more snug alternative, we recommend looking into the also lightweight Performs consistently in cold conditions instead. 

We measured the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's stack to be 26.4 mm thick at the heel.

This is significantly shorter than average but still has plenty of foam underfoot for us to enjoy well-cushioned landings over the course of testing this boot. 

Naturally, we expect the forefoot stack to match the heel but there's a bit of a discrepancy with the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX. Using the measuring guidelines set by World Athletics, we measured the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's forefoot stack to actually be 23.8 mm thick. So, technically, it's not a true zero-drop boot. 

This amount of foam underfoot is on par with our current lab average and is enough to effectively mute out the harsh terrain below. 

The difference in our stack measurements means that the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX actually sports a 2.6 mm heel drop. This is still a more parallel-to-the-ground experience than most hiking boots offer and will only be noticeable to true zero-drop purists. 

Pressing our durometer against the midsole yields a reading of 22 HA. This level of softness provides a balanced level of cushioning 

Apart from providing good impact dampening, the midsole is also quite responsive. It has a springy rebound that feels more like a trail running shoe that gives us a little extra pep in our step while hiking in this boot. What's more, it means that we could break out into a jog at a moment's notice and comfortably scamper along the trails like a breeze. 

We placed the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX in our freezer for twenty minutes to see the goods of cold conditions on the midsole. Once appropriately chilled, we pressed our durometer against it once more and got a much softer-than-average reading of 25.3 HA. This 14.8% increase in firmness means that the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX performs very consistently no matter how frosty it gets and will provide balanced cushioning all year round. 

We measured the insole to be 7.4 mm thick which is quite a bit thicker than our current lab average. This provided us with great arch support and a cushy footbed to sink into that really elevated our levels of comfort while testing this boot. 

According to the product specs, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX features Altra's Original Footshape which is supposed to be the brand's widest, most spacious fit.

However, when we retrieved a mould of the shoe's interiors using custom gel, it showed a pretty standard measurement in the widest part of the toebox. At 94.9 mm, it is only about a milimeter wider than average.

This is odd considering that the Heel stack lab shoe returned a notably higher reading of 97.8 mm. You might as well consider the Altra Olympus 6 Hike Mid GTX which is also built on the Original last but showed 98.8 mm in the widest part.

On the bright side, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX does provide that natural foot-shaped silhouette we've come to love from Altra. Its square toebox shape has ZERO tapering towards the toes!

With a calliper reading of 80.9 mm near the big toe, the boot gave our toes plenty of room to splay out comfortably all throughout the hike.

Conversely, having so much internal real estate isn't ideal for people with narrow feet as the latter will most likely shift around within the boot when traversing uneven terrains, which takes a toll on stability and can exacerbate foot fatigue.

However, the vertical space of this hiking boot turned out to be on par with the average at 27.5 mm. It didn't cause any pressure on top of our toes.

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX, for all its comfort, isn't a very stable shoe as demonstrated by how much lateral movement it allows as we shift our weight from side to side. This made traversing uneven terrains a little more challenging as we had to be more mindful of our steps and make lots of foot adjustments for balance. While this is fine when it comes to day hikes, we would recommend a more stable shoe like the Keen Pyrenees for long-haul backpacking adventures that involve carrying heavy loads. 

With its minimalist nature, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX did not resist our manual rigidity assessment so much, leading to a below-average stiffness score of 3 out of 5.

This Altra boot relies on a wide and grounded platform to provide surefooted landings as opposed to the stout midsoles and stabilising components we see on most hiking boots.

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's heel counter is somewhat flexible and earns a middle-of-the-road stiffness score of 3 out of 5. So while it does provide a secure lockdown that comfortably holds our heel in place, it doesn't do much to mitigate the rearfoot from rolling laterally. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's midsole is about as wide as our current lab average at 110 mm according to our caliper measurements. This gives us a good amount of platform for relatively stable landings. 

Back at the heel, we found the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's midsole to be narrower than average at only 84.4 mm wide. This didn't really present us with any issues while testing, but those more accustomed to a wider base at the heel should look into the We measured the Lone Peak Hiker 2s stack to be 26.4 mm thick at the heel instead. 

We secured the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX in our flexibility testing machine and found that it takes as little as 12.0N of force to bend by 30 degrees. That makes it more than half as flexible as the average hiking boot!

The flexibility of the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX is thanks in part to the configuration of its lugs which are designed to line up with the bones of our foot, allowing the shoe to bend along with the natural flexion of our foot with relative ease.

This certainly plays a role in how comfy and forgiving the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX feels underfoot, however it does come at the expense of stability, especially when carrying a heavy pack.

We also repeated the flex test after leaving the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX in the freezer for twenty minutes and found that it only became 13.9% stiffer when exposed to the cold. In fact, with a post-freezer requirement of 34.1N to bend the boot to the desired point, the chilled Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX is more flexible than the average boot at room temperature. This incredibly consistent performance means that the boot should be just as pliable and forgiving on the foot during frigid winter hikes. That said, we still wouldn't recommend trudging through heavy snow or ice in this boot. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX is a lean, mean, trail-crushing machine that tips our scale at only 12 oz (339g). 

As such, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX feels incredibly feathery underfoot which not only makes it great for long hikes with lots of ascents and descents, but also unburdensome enough to support light jogs for whenever the need for speed kicks in. 

To see how breathable the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX is, we pumped it full of smoke and observed how easily it was able to vent from the boot. As we can see from the footage, the smoke was only able to escape through the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's porous, semi-gusseted tongue while the rest of the upper remains relatively airtight. This leads us to give the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX a breathability score of 2 out of 5. This means that the boot will certainly feel stuffy during hikes on sweltering summer days but still has some level of airflow to keep it from becoming a stinky foot sauna. 

The Adidas Terrex Free Hiker 2, on the other hand, lets the smoke dissipate rather evenly throughout the shoe, making it much more suited for hikes on hot, dry days. 

Inspecting a cross-section of the mostly mesh upper, we see that it entirely blocks out the backlight, thus confirming the insular, weatherproof nature of the shoe. Just as light isn't able to peak through any pores of the upper, water is similarly repelled unless the boot gets drenched. 

To see how the mech is able to repel water so efficiently, we took a look at it under the microscope which reveals an incredibly uniform and dense weave pattern with almost no gaps between the braids.  

Pressing our durometer against the midsole yields a reading of 22 HA. This level of softness provides a balanced level of cushioning 

Apart from providing good impact dampening, the midsole is also quite responsive. It has a springy rebound that feels more like a trail running shoe that gives us a little extra pep in our step while hiking in this boot. What's more, it means that we could break out into a jog at a moment's notice and comfortably scamper along the trails like a breeze. 

To simulate extreme wear and tear, we subjected the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX to a series of Dremel tests, starting with the toebox. Spinning at 5K RPM, we set the tool's abrasive element to an unreinforced section of mesh with 3.2N of force.

While we were able to pierce through the mesh by the end of the twelve-second test, the hole left doesn't span the entire point of contact and the overall integrity of the toebox wasn't greatly affected, so we give the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX a middle-of-the-road toebox durability score of 3 out of 5. 

The heel counter proved to be an even better adversary to our Dremel which merely skated off the lining material and left the padding beneath intact. 

This stellar performance leads us to give the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX a perfect 5 out of 5 for heel padding durability. 

The MaxTrac rubber compound that makes up the outsole gave us a durometer reading of 85.5 HC which is right around our current lab average. This usually denotes a good mix of grip and durability, the latter of which will be tested in the next section. 

This time spinning at 10K RPM, we set the Dremel against one of the lugs which immediately kicked up a flurry of rubber particles. Not a promising sign. 

After twenty-two seconds of grinding, we measured the indentation left behind with a tyre tread gauge and found that 1.2 mm of material was lost to the test. This makes the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's outsole less durable than the average hiking boot which loses less under similar circumstances. This further confirms that this boot isn't well-suited for harsh, gravelly trails which will erode the lugs at a much faster rate than softer dirt trails. The Adidas Terrex Free Hiker 2 sports a much more durable outsole with a similarly light trail shoe-esque frame. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's outsole boasts less rubber than average at only 2.1 mm thick according to our caliper measurements. While this doesn't do the boot any favors in terms of durability, it does contribute to its lightweight frame. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's lugs are 4 mm thick according to our calliper measurements, putting them on par with our current lab average. 

These multi-directional, chevron-shaped lugs provided us with excellent traction during our test hikes on dirt trails and well-manicured park trails. 

However, the boot did let us down when we tested it on more technical, gravelly trails where we felt decidedly less surefooted in our strides. We also recommend avoiding slick or muddy surfaces in this boot. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX doesn't feature any reflective elements, so we don't recommend walking along dimly lit roads at night without additional high-vis gear. 

At 9 mm thick according to our caliper measurements, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's tongue is slightly less padded than our current lab average. It's still cushy enough to feel incredibly comfortable across the instep and effectively protects us from lace bite while testing this boot. 

Unlike many other hiking boots we've tested so far, the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's tongue is only semi-gusseted. While this might help in shaving off a few grams from the overall weight, it does mean that little bits of grit and debris did occasionally make their way into the boot during our test hikes. 

There's a cord-like finger loop at the heel of the Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX to help pull the boot on.

However, despite this feature, we still found the boot difficult to squeeze into without loosening up the laces significantly. 

The Hoka Anacapa Mid GTX's insole isn't glued in so it can easily be replaced with a custom orthotic if necessary.