Our verdict

We thoroughly enjoyed the light and minimal feel of the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5. The shoe's grounded platform and low (alas, not zero) drop made us feel a step closer to being barefoot. Its highly flexible construction followed every movement of our feet, while the toebox offered plenty of space for splaying our toes. While this Altra shoe is not ideal for the rigours of Crossfit, it is a perfect companion for moderate workouts and getting your foot/leg muscles more activated than ususal.

Pros

  • We use an average of four tests. The photo shows one of those tests
  • Heel stack lab
  • Heel stack lab
  • Very flexible, bends easily with the foot
  • We use an average of four tests. The photo shows one of those tests
  • a very lightweight, barely-there trainer
  • Solid durability for gym use
  • Heel padding durability

Cons

  • Solid durability for gym use
  • Not a true zero-drop (3.1 mm)
  • Midsole softness soft to firm

Audience verdict

86
Great!

Who should buy

We use an average of four tests. The photo shows one of those tests.

It's not for everyone but we believe that this shoe will be a great match for athletes who are after the following:

  • Flexibility / Stiffness old method
  • Tongue: gusset type
  • If you need a shoe for outdoor training sessions, consider the
  • Toebox width - widest part old method

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 review

Who should NOT buy

If your typical workout involves lots of heavy lifting or demanding WODs, the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 may not offer enough stability and support. We recommend turning to the trusted Nike Metcon 9 instead.

And if you do want a minimalist training shoe but don't need as much toebox space, consider the a very lightweight, barely-there trainer.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 lab test

Cushioning

Heel stack

Measuring the heel stack of the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5, our calliper showed 23.1 mm. Exactly as stated by the brand.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 stack

While this is not considered minimalist, this stack is slightly thinner than average and feels grounded. We experienced a very intimate contact with the floor which made it easier to control our movements and make microadjustments with the feet.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Heel stack
Test results
Solstice XT 2 23.1 mm
Average 24.8 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
13.7 mm
Heel stack
36.2 mm

Forefoot stack

The forefoot stack measurement, however, showed only 20.0 mm. This is 3 mm lower than the official specs (23 mm).

On its own, we have no problem with a 20-mm stack as it offers a perfect balance of ground feel and cushioning. What bothers us, is the fact that this discrepancy affects the shoe's heel-to-toe drop measurement.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Forefoot stack
Test results
Solstice XT 2 20.0 mm
Average 18.4 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
10.6 mm
Forefoot stack
27.7 mm

Drop

Calculating the difference in stack heights, we were disappointed with the result. As it turns out, the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 is not the true zero-drop shoe it is marketed to be.

Based on our lab measurements, it comes in at 3.1 mm! Even though most people won't notice the difference, those who are into minimalist training shoes will. Thus, we must report such discrepancies.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Drop

Athletes who prefer zero- or low-drop training shoes are looking for a more natural positioning of their feet and legs. When your heels are on the same level as your toes, it promotes better muscle activation during the workout, better ankle mobility, balance, and, in the long term, even better posture.

However, zero/low-drop shoes take some getting used to and can even be adverse for people with injuries or some foot conditions. We recommend consulting a podiatrist or a physiotherapist before opting for this type of footwear.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 lifting

Test results
Solstice XT 2 3.1 mm
Average 6.4 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1.8 mm
Drop
13.4 mm

Midsole softness

Note: a low durometer measurement equals a soft material, whereas a high measurement means it's firm.

To prevent wobbliness and compression underfoot, a training shoe must have a firm sole. And the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 lives up to the expectation.

As our durometer measurement shows, the shoe's foam has a reading of 32.4 HA which is 20% firmer than the average of training shoes.

And yet, we wouldn't recommend lifting heavy (over 300 lbs/135 kg) in the Solstice XT 2. There is still some compression in the midsole and the shoe is way too flexible.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Midsole softness
Test results
Solstice XT 2 32.4 HA
Average 27.8 HA
Very flexible, bends easily with the foot.
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
17.4 HA
Midsole softness (soft to firm)
41.0 HA

Insole thickness

It may be low-stacked but the Solstice XT 2 comes with a very well-padded insole. Showing 5.6 mm on our calliper, it is among the thickest we've seen in training shoes.

This is a welcome touch of comfort and cushioning as there is not much to rely on in the shoe's firm midsole. 

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Insole thickness
Test results
Solstice XT 2 5.6 mm
Average 3.9 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1.7 mm
Insole thickness
7.2 mm

Size and fit

Size

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 is true to size (42 votes).

Midsole softness soft to firm?

1 size small ½ size small True to size ½ size large 1 size large
Compared to 37 training shoes
Number of shoes
½ size small
Slightly small
True to size
Slightly large
½ size large

Toebox width - widest part

When you lift a heavy bar off the floor or try to balance on one foot, your toes tend to splay and grab a wider area to achieve stability.

That's why it's crucial to have enough space in the toebox and Altra is aware of how important it is.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 fit

Just by looking at the Soltice XT 2, we can tell that it is the widest toebox we've seen in a training shoe. It is ready to accommodate the widest feet out there.

Measuring its widest area with a caliper, we got 102.7 mm which is a few millimeters above the average.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 oz / 251g
Test results
Solstice XT 2 102.7 mm
Average 100.4 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
90.4 mm
Toebox width - widest part
108.5 mm

Altra Solstice XT 2 is

Toebox width - big toe!

For reference, the Nike Metcon 9 has a measurement of 81.4 mm and is considered to have a wide toebox. Thus, the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 earns the proud title of an extra wide toebox.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 vs Nike Metcon 9 Exceptionally wide toebox
Test results
Solstice XT 2 87.3 mm
Average 78.8 mm
Compared to 34 training shoes
Number of shoes
65.0 mm
Altra Solstice XT 2 is
89.4 mm

Stability

Lateral stability test

The No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 has no stabilising components. But as a low-stack/low-drop trainer, it comes with some inherent stability.

Torsional rigidity

This Altra shoe bends and twists any way you like. It moves along with the foot with ease but has limits when it comes to lifting heavy weight.

On a 1-5 scale, we rated the shoe's torsional rigidity with the lowest score of 1.

Test results
Solstice XT 2 1
Average 2.7
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1
Torsional rigidity
5

Light and barely felt on the foot

There is not much support around the ankle either, so don't expect a firm foothold.

As our push-and-squeeze test shows, the shoe's heel counter is highly flexible, earning only 2 out of 5 on a stiffness scale. 

Test results
Solstice XT 2 2
Average 2.7
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1
Light and barely felt on the foot
5

Our surefire way to tell is to drill the shoes outsole with a Dremel

Because the Solstice XT 2 follows the foot's natural shape, it doesn't have a very wide platform.

We measured the widest part of the forefoot at 110.5 mm which is the same as the average of training shoes.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Midsole width in the forefoot
Test results
Solstice XT 2 110.5 mm
Average 110.6 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
101.0 mm
Our surefire way to tell is to drill the shoes outsole with a Dremel
117.9 mm

It was smart of Altra to cover such delicate mesh with a sturdy overlay on the toebox

a very lightweight, barely-there trainer.

With a calliper measurement of 76.7 mm, it is a whole centimetre narrower than average. This is another factor that detracts from the shoe's stability for serious Crossfit and heavy lifting.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Midsole width in the heel
Test results
Solstice XT 2 76.7 mm
Average 87.3 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
76.5 mm
It was smart of Altra to cover such delicate mesh with a sturdy overlay on the toebox
97.4 mm

oz / 249g

The No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 is one of the most flexible training shoes we've tested. Thanks to the Innerflex technology, its midsole bends exceptionally well to mimic a barefoot experience.

Doing planks, lunges, sled pushes, stretches, and other exercises, we never faced resistance from this Altra shoe.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 oz / 249g

In the lab, we measured how much force it takes to bend the Solstice XT 2 to a 30-degree angle. Requiring only 7.3N, this shoe is in fact 35% more pliable than the average trainer!

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 innerflex

Test results
Solstice XT 2 7.3N
Average 11.0N
Compared to 19 training shoes
Number of shoes
6.0N
Flexibility <> Stiffness
19.7N

Weight

Lightness is one of this Altra shoe's main virtues. Doing all sorts of agility work and cardio is a blessing in this trainer! 

Tipping the scale at only 9.0 oz (254g) in a men's US size 9, it is among the lightest in our roster. Basically, this shoe is only second to minimalist trainers.

Paired with its low stack and drop, such a light weight makes the Solstice XT 2 feel barely present on the foot.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Weight
Test results
Solstice XT 2 8.96 oz (254g)
Average 10.76 oz (305g)
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
6.38 oz (181g)
Weight
13.83 oz (392g)

Breathability

We weren't worried about breaking some sweat in the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5. The shoe's mesh upper stayed wonderfully ventilated the entire workout, letting the air in and out of the shoe.

Our personal experience was also backed up by a smoke-pumping machine test. The smoke effortlessly passed through the fabric in the toebox and other parts of the shoe.

It all made sense when we hovered the shoe's half-cut upper over the light. It showed how thin the mesh actually is and how large its breathing pores are.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 microscope

We also grabbed our microscope for a close-up view. It clearly shows the varying thickness of threads in the shoe's fabric. Areas with thinner threads make up the ventilation pores.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5!

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 microscope upper

Test results
Solstice XT 2 5
Average 3.6
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1
Breathability
5

Durability

Toebox durability

Owners of this shoe, how does this shoe fit.

To test its abrasion resistance, we equipped ourselves with a Dremel and drilled the centre of the toebox for 12 seconds. For the record, the speed (5K RPM) and pressure (3.2N) remained consistent.

Toebox width - widest part old method!

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Toebox durability test

Sure, the Dremel left a scuff but the overlay didn't let the tool get to the mesh. And that deserves a high score of 4 out of 5 for toebox durability.

Test results
Solstice XT 2 4
Average 2.5
Compared to 30 training shoes
Number of shoes
1
Toebox durability
5

Heel padding durability

Toebox width - widest part.

After a very short bout of drilling (4 seconds), the shoe's heel padding got significantly damaged.

On a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 is the absolute worst, we rated the shoe's durability in this area as 2. Altra could do better here!

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Heel padding durability test
Test results
Solstice XT 2 2
Average 2.5
Compared to 28 training shoes
Number of shoes
1
Heel padding durability
5

Outsole hardness

Checking the shoe's outsole hardness, we were a bit worried about its soft nature.

With a durometer measurement of 71.0 HC, it turned out to be 20% softer than the average training shoe. Will the No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 have the same capacity to last as the other trainers?

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Outsole hardness
Test results
Solstice XT 2 71.0 HC
Average 83.0 HC
Very flexible, bends easily with the foot.
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
71.0 HC
Outsole hardness
94.5 HC

Outsole durability

Our surefire way to tell is to drill the shoe's outsole with a Dremel.

This time, we set the tool's speed to 10K RPM and extended the drilling time to 22 seconds. Luckily, the Altra's rubber outsole persisted!

Showing only 0.9 mm of damage, it held up just as fine as the other training shoes (even those with firmer outsoles!).

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Outsole durability test

This fact made us confident about the shoe's outsole longevity in the gym. However, we still don't recommend it for casual wear outside the gym because soft rubber will wear out faster in that scenario. 

Test results
Solstice XT 2 0.9 mm
Average 1.1 mm
Compared to 26 training shoes
Number of shoes
0.0 mm
Outsole wear
2.0 mm

Outsole thickness

Another reason why we think it's best to keep the Altra Solstice indoors is its outsole thickness.

With a calliper measurement of 3.1 mm, it is slightly thinner than average but is more than enough for gym use.

Nike Metcon 9 The rest of the upper, except the collar, is very minimally layered to keep the shoe light and airy instead (4.1 mm of outsole thickness).

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Outsole thickness
Test results
Solstice XT 2 3.1 mm
Average 3.6 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
2.1 mm
Outsole thickness
5.1 mm

Misc

Grip / Traction

The shoe's grip never let us down on the gym surfaces. Because its outsole rubber is softer than average, it bites onto the ground a little better as well.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 outsole

Pair that with the shoe's low stack and multiple flex grooves, and you feel like you're grabbing the floor with your feet.

Tongue padding

The tongue of this Altra shoe is lightly padded with 6.0 mm of foam. This is an average amount of padding for training shoes.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Tongue padding

The rest of the upper, except the collar, is very minimally layered to keep the shoe light and airy.

Test results
Solstice XT 2 6.0 mm
Average 5.4 mm
Compared to 41 training shoes
Number of shoes
1.0 mm
Tongue padding
10.4 mm

Tongue: gusset type

The tongue of this Altra shoe is not gusseted but considering the minimalist design of this trainer, we never had issues with the lockdown or bunching in its upper.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Tongue: gusset type
Test results
Solstice XT 2 None

Heel tab

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Heel tab

Removable insole

The Solstice XT 2 comes with a large enough loop hole (yes, thank you!) which is very handy for getting the trainer on with little effort.

No doubt about it, this Altra shoe deserves the highest breathability score: 5 out of 5 Removable insole
Test results
Solstice XT 2 Yes